| # | Title | Artist |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Blessings | Story, Laura |
| 2 | But Not for Me | Gershwin, George |
| 3 | Die on This Hill | Spiro, Sienna |
| 4 | Via Dolorosa | Patty, Sandi |
| 5 | Because He Lives | Bill & Gloria Gaither |
| 6 | Then Came the Morning | The Gaithers |
| 7 | River Flows in You | Yiruma |
| 8 | Risk It All | Mars, Bruno |
| 9 | Interstellar (Main Theme) | Pietschmann, Patrik |
| 10 | The Visitor | Spiro, Sienna |
| 11 | So Easy (To Fall in Love) | Dean, Olivia |
| 12 | Hallelujah | Cohen, Leonard |
| 13 | She Used to Be Mine | Bareilles, Sara |
| 14 | For Good | Wicked |
| 15 | Easter Medley | Wells, Marcia |
| 16 | Honor Him / Now We Are Free | Jacob's Piano |
| 17 | Rise Again | Holm, Dallas |
| 18 | Can't Help Falling in Love | Presley, Elvis |
| 19 | Living Hope | Wickham, Phil |
| 20 | Golden | KPop Demon Hunters |
| 21 | Man I Need | Dean, Olivia |
| 22 | Goodness of God | Winans, Cece |
| 23 | Passacaglia | Handel, George Frederick |
| 24 | My Days | The Notebook: The Musical |
| 25 | A Thousand Years | Perri, Christina |
| 26 | He Lives | Joe Harris |
| 27 | The Holy City | Maybrick, Michael |
| 28 | Piano Man | Joel, Billy |
| 29 | Holy Forever | Tomlin, Chris |
| 30 | You Stole the Show | Spiro, Sienna |
| 31 | Hallelujah | Cohen, Leonard |
| 32 | Were You There? (When They Crucified My Lord) | Signature Score |
| 33 | Because He Lives | Gaither, Bill |
| 34 | Journey to the Past | Anastasia [2017] |
| 35 | The Winner Takes It All | ABBA |
| 36 | Out There | The Hunchback of Notre Dame [Musical] |
| 37 | ICARUS | Tony Ann |
| 38 | You Raise Me Up | Groban, Josh |
| 39 | A Million Dreams | The Greatest Showman |
| 40 | Maybe This Time | Cabaret |
| 41 | Over the Rainbow | Garland, Judy |
| 42 | Blessings | Story, Laura |
| 43 | Piano Man | Joel, Billy |
| 44 | Waving Through a Window | Dear Evan Hansen |
| 45 | Vienna | Joel, Billy |
| 46 | Hopeless War | The Outsiders: The Musical |
| 47 | Make You Feel My Love | Adele |
| 48 | Amazing Grace (My Chains Are Gone) | Tomlin, Chris |
| 49 | Part of Your World | The Little Mermaid (1989) |
| 50 | Slipping Through My Fingers | Mamma Mia! |